Pretendian Hunters

Pretendian Hunters

Released Tuesday, 4th June 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Pretendian Hunters

Pretendian Hunters

Pretendian Hunters

Pretendian Hunters

Tuesday, 4th June 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

Canada and funded by you.

0:05

A. Don't? What's? The. Worst thing

0:07

that could happen with the series. The.

0:09

Worst thing that could happen is that are

0:12

information as bad and the person. Is actually

0:14

a native? Could you imagine? I would just

0:16

be like crawling under a rock and and

0:18

dying is what I would do. Worse case

0:20

scenario is that we get it wrong and

0:22

then we look like goddamn clowns to hundreds

0:24

or thousands of people and also like we've

0:26

really screwed someone over. Yeah. That's the

0:29

kind of thing that will haunt you forever. A

0:31

mistake like that is our worst nightmare.

0:33

But. It's also someone's reality. Today's.

0:36

Episode is about a pretending and hunter who may

0:38

have gone too far. It's. About

0:40

what happens when pretending investigations

0:42

go wrong. To

0:45

calculate their title taking and hang the

0:47

other neck of people who are falsely

0:50

claiming. I just find it has it's just

0:52

a very rotten heart both feet. Schooling

1:01

now my news feed on a

1:03

hot summer day. Got

1:07

a D n a

1:09

zoo aim who say.

1:12

Would much rather sticky bar don't

1:14

know the hot summer saw. Go

1:18

chase them. Pastor is on to

1:20

the job is done. When

1:34

you use As a P Concur Solutions

1:36

to automate your business finances, you'll be

1:39

ready for anything. Except

1:43

the new of dog winding up with

1:46

your lunch. With.

1:49

As a P concur, you can be

1:51

ready for. With as a peak occur you can be

1:53

ready for. Almost anything.

1:54

Almost anything. Take. Control

1:57

of your business Finance Today I

1:59

concur. Dot Com. concur.com.

2:08

From Canaland Podcast, this is Pretendians, a show

2:10

where we investigate the impact that fakes, frauds

2:12

and phonies have on real Native people. My

2:14

name is Robert Jago. I'm a freelance writer

2:16

from the Kwantlen First Nation and Nooksack Indian

2:18

Tribe. And I'm Angel Ellis, a

2:20

citizen of the Muskogee Creek Nation located

2:22

in Ocmulgee, Oklahoma. I've been a writer,

2:25

editor, journalist for about 15 years. Angel,

2:33

I'd like you to meet Jacqueline Keeler. My

2:35

name is Jacqueline Keeler. I

2:37

am a citizen of the Navajo Nation. My

2:40

father is Yankton Sioux from South

2:42

Dakota. I'm a journalist and author,

2:45

and I have been doing research into

2:47

the allegations of ethnic

2:50

fraud, commonly called pretendianism. Non-Native

2:52

listeners may not be familiar with

2:54

Jacqueline Keeler, but they're likely familiar

2:57

with her work. Jacqueline Keeler is

2:59

a Navajo and co-founder of the

3:01

group Eradicating Offensive Native Masketry.

3:03

They claim the buck tooth red

3:05

face image is offensive to Native

3:07

American culture. I love Wahoo!

3:09

Fuck you! It's a caricature!

3:11

Get over here! No way!

3:13

Yeah! Woo! Woo! Woo! Woo!

3:16

Woo! Woo! Jacqueline and her

3:18

team succeeded in getting most of those awful

3:20

mascots away from major sports, like the chief

3:22

Wahoo mascot of the Cleveland Indians, now known

3:24

as the Cleveland Guardians, as a result of

3:26

her campaign. They promote stereotypes, outdated stereotypes

3:29

about Native people, and they pigeonhole us

3:31

so that real Native people aren't seen

3:33

for who we are, and nobody knows

3:35

anything about us. And she also got

3:37

the Washington Reds to ditch that

3:39

name. Now they're the Washington

3:41

Commanders. Can we beep? That's

3:44

like such a... Did

3:46

I just go beep? Okay. So

3:48

that's one of her projects. Another has been

3:50

leading the charge to identify and expose pretendians.

3:53

She's been quite effective at that, too. CBC

3:56

News gets the credit for exposing Buffy St.

3:58

Marie and how she mischiefed... represented her

4:00

indigenous identity. But it was

4:03

actually Jacqueline Keeler who first discovered and researched

4:05

this. Yeah I'm the one who found

4:07

out she wasn't who she was. At first

4:09

Jacqueline was a Buffy fan like a lot of

4:11

natives. She used to have a radio show and

4:13

she used a Buffy song in every episode. I

4:16

had as a sort of theme song to my

4:18

show a song I carry it on by Buffy

4:20

St. Marie you know every morning I have a

4:22

show I'd like it all works out this thing

4:24

to it like it all like jazz and stuff

4:27

and get myself going. Someone

4:33

in the comments basically said oh did you

4:35

know that she's a fraud. I was

4:38

suddenly having a sinking feeling when I

4:40

realized that she never was able to

4:42

really identify her family or any

4:44

proof at all that she you know

4:46

had come from Saskatchewan or even Canada

4:49

and and I was like oh my god

4:51

this seems like a pretendian. And the first

4:53

thing that popped up was that she had

4:56

been on the Massachusetts birth index was being

4:58

born in Stoneham Massachusetts and

5:00

I was like whoa what

5:02

does this mean I mean and and

5:04

so we were able to really piece

5:06

together that that she was born there

5:08

and this these were her actual relatives

5:10

her Italian father and her you know

5:12

white pilgrim mother. There's an Italian American

5:14

community there that felt very rejected by

5:16

her that she was ashamed of them

5:18

you know there are stories in

5:20

the printed at the time of

5:23

her driving her her Italian uncles away and

5:25

screaming at them you know because she was

5:27

ashamed that people might realize that they were

5:29

her actual she looks like them she looks

5:31

exactly like them you know and you know it

5:33

was all there was pretty apparent

5:36

that she was lying and she's lied about

5:38

it so much it's just completely ridiculous to

5:40

fall back on that at this point you

5:42

know she never told the truth about

5:44

it she was lying that's

5:47

the end of the story. Angel how did

5:49

you feel about the Buffy expose? Oh

5:51

my gosh the Buffy expose kind of

5:53

rocked my world because like it was

5:55

like generations of my family who were

5:57

like hurt you know how when you're dead

6:00

That really love that song and you

6:02

have great memories of that song in

6:04

the car and then it turns out

6:06

that they're not actually like you. It

6:08

was really disappointing because she was always one was

6:10

figures that in for any sort of canadian think

6:13

the always. Dragged. Around prepped her

6:15

up. It's just disappointing because of

6:17

her status in the community. She

6:19

was on Sesame Street. And

6:21

you're like of native kids like watching

6:23

Sesame Street. And like the first time you've ever

6:25

seen. That it's like saying and

6:27

so. It kind of take. Makes

6:30

your childhood allied with a the it. It's like

6:32

what is going on here. Of

6:34

is just one of jacqueline So many

6:37

subjects where we're going to focus on

6:39

today is or main effort to identify.

6:41

pretend it's pretending it's and universities in

6:43

the media Oliver. And she made

6:45

a list. I

6:48

created a google doc. And I am

6:50

at the down and as idea which was. I'll

6:53

now maybe twenty five people I knew as

6:55

an and I open a full etc will

6:57

was never opened his private less but if

6:59

someone asked to have access to it we

7:01

would let them. but only one sweet they

7:03

gave their real names. We. Were

7:05

able to ascertain that they were actually

7:07

Nader's at they were professional in various

7:09

fields like so they're talking about in

7:11

colleagues in their field stripes. As a

7:13

the we open less up to them

7:16

it was We we saw the two

7:18

hundred because we need to finish the

7:20

investigation. Ah we have says received several

7:22

hundred more. Name's. Sue.

7:24

Hundred names were added to this google doc.

7:26

All of them are people who are suspected

7:28

of being pretentious. Now. As hurt

7:30

Jacqueline says as was priceless.

7:33

And. How do you know about Robert? Because

7:35

a wasn't private? The may have been private

7:38

when was first released but once it was

7:40

out in the world he was everywhere on

7:42

Reddit on Twitter, put up on people's blogs.

7:44

people make copies, answer them around. it was

7:47

very is fine and made of social media.

7:49

As you know is a pretty tight knit

7:51

and small world. Once where did this list

7:53

got around? Everyone was checking to see who

7:55

was on it. i

7:58

as jacqueline if you sorted any names before adding

8:00

them to the list. We

8:05

did remove some if we knew off the bat that

8:07

they were legit. I mean, I don't know. We really

8:09

were working with people who were seriously questionable. We wanted

8:12

to find out the truth. Mostly we

8:14

just accepted what they wrote. I think if

8:16

someone we allowed access to the list to

8:18

submit a bunch of claims that were spurious

8:21

or obviously ridiculous, we just got

8:23

rid of those. But mostly they were

8:25

chosen by people who are professionals in

8:27

those fields, native to professionals who

8:30

have suspected fraud in their fields. They were the

8:32

ones who chose the people in the list. And

8:34

some of them, I put a legend because we

8:36

had not confirmed these cases and we needed to

8:38

do so. This was not

8:40

a list of confirmed Britannians. This

8:42

was a list of people who were deemed

8:44

to be likely suspects. We

8:46

actually can identify that ancestor and they are

8:49

from the tribe they are claiming. No matter

8:51

how far back it is, we mark them

8:53

as verified. We verify that.

8:55

So the problem is very few of these claims

8:57

pan out and we've only been able to

8:59

verify like seven people. Wait. So

9:02

there were people on this list

9:04

of possible Britannians who she later

9:07

verified as being legit. Yes.

9:10

So for example, one of the people targeted

9:12

elsewhere by Jacqueline Keeler was Tara Hauska. She's

9:15

the citizen of the Kuchicheng First Nation. She's

9:17

a prominent land defender, a lawyer fighting for

9:19

Trumpa rights, and she was friend and center

9:21

at Standing Rock. But online,

9:23

Keeler cast doubts about her ancestry by

9:25

investigating her mother's ancestry and determining that

9:28

her connection was too distant to count.

9:31

But Hauska is a registered native through

9:33

her father's side. Jacqueline admits

9:35

that some of the names on the list were

9:37

not actually Britannians, but she doesn't see that as

9:39

a problem. She argues that there was actually an

9:41

upside for people who were called out on the

9:43

list for maybe being frauds because it

9:46

gave them an opportunity to clear their names. Fax

9:50

can actually relieve someone from accusations

9:53

of fraud, but it can also show

9:55

that fraud is really rampant. I mean,

9:57

the initial list that we verified. include

10:00

200 names and most of

10:02

them in academia in some form. And out

10:05

of that 97% of them we

10:07

could not verify their travel claims. Why don't

10:10

they, if they really have an issue, why

10:12

don't they just present their evidence? So

10:14

it's kind of like if you have nothing to hide, you

10:16

have nothing to fear, I guess. Jacqueline

10:19

says she and her secret group of

10:21

researchers aren't out to get anybody. She

10:23

says they actually prefer it when they

10:25

find out someone isn't a pretendian. In

10:28

fact, we found that CSU San Marcos

10:30

professor who was actually being 100% accurate

10:32

in her description of her

10:34

dissent. We actually threw a little online

10:37

Zoom party, our researchers, because we were just

10:39

so happy to find something we could actually

10:41

confirm. Like we don't, it kills us to

10:43

see that people are lying. It's not something

10:45

we want to find. She says

10:47

she doesn't want to find pretendians, but when

10:49

she does find them, she sees it as

10:51

very important to call them out. You

10:53

know, what we are dealing with is fraud.

10:56

I'm investigating a huge fraud case. I

10:58

mean, a case of fraud happening in this country,

11:00

which is probably stealing billions of dollars

11:03

away from Native people. And that's not

11:05

an exaggeration. If you document how much

11:07

their families own their land, everything, we

11:09

know how much they got out of

11:11

this. And so we want to calculate

11:13

their total taking and hang that on

11:15

the neck of people who

11:17

are falsely claiming because these people, as

11:20

I've been quoted as saying before, their

11:22

ancestors, their family members were on the

11:24

white supremacy party bus. And these

11:27

people are driving Native people out

11:29

of their professional careers. They are

11:31

impoverishing Native families because many Native

11:33

families depend on people who

11:35

can get a PhD to help support everyone on

11:37

the res. She says

11:39

if you add up all of the salaries

11:41

of pretendians and universities that are instead going

11:44

to imposters, it adds up to an

11:46

astounding level of fraud. Investigating

11:48

a massive fraud case is what journalists do.

11:50

And that's why they actually make the world

11:53

a better place. Honestly, I

11:56

agree with the points she's making about

11:58

Natives losing opportunities. And

12:01

I agree with the point she's making about investigations

12:04

and what journalists do and that

12:06

it's important work. That's

12:08

what we're trying to do here, right? I

12:10

mean, sure, that's the idea. So

12:13

let me ask you this, like, what's her criteria?

12:15

Like, when we started

12:17

making this series, we set up

12:19

some rules for ourselves. Yeah, it's

12:21

not enough just to verify that they're not

12:24

indigenous. I mean, there are lots and lots

12:26

of people who are pretendians, and most of

12:28

them aren't really harming anybody but themselves. So

12:32

to make someone worth investigating, we agreed on a

12:34

three-part test. Just first

12:36

off, off the basics, they're not indigenous. So

12:38

that means they're not a citizen of a

12:40

nation. They're not part of that nation. They're

12:43

not tribally enrolled. They're not federally registered. Or

12:45

they have no ability to be any of

12:47

those. Also, the tribe exists.

12:49

It is a legitimate real tribe.

12:52

That's number one. Number two is

12:54

that they're prominent enough to

12:58

have an impact on the

13:00

interests of actual Native people. So

13:03

they're not just, you know,

13:05

so-and-so at the gas station who says,

13:08

oh, you're Native, I'm Native too. We

13:10

don't care about that. It's about

13:12

the ones who are doing things

13:14

that are changing our politics, changing

13:17

the culture, who are, again, like,

13:19

making money off of this. The key

13:21

takeaway is that there's some sort

13:23

of harm. The third

13:25

criteria is that their community rejects them.

13:28

The tribe they claim doesn't claim them.

13:30

There are people on the ground from

13:33

that place who say that this person, by

13:35

our standards, is not one of us. That

13:38

last part, I think, is really, really

13:40

important, and it's what a lot of

13:42

pretendian stories have missed out on, is

13:45

going into the community and finding out

13:47

how does citizenship work here. We

13:50

can't just come in from on high

13:53

from a non-Native media organization.

13:56

We can't go into someone else's nation and say, that

13:58

person's not a real one of you. I

14:00

mean, we need to go and talk to them and

14:02

find out what their standards are and apply those standards.

14:05

So that's our criteria. And I asked Jacqueline what

14:08

hers are. The criteria is in

14:10

the definition of pretend innocent that we use,

14:12

which is that they are professionals in their

14:14

field. They are seeking to

14:16

be our spokespeople. They have monetization

14:18

schemes going to monetize the claims,

14:21

but that sort of thing. So by

14:23

definition, these people are consequential and these

14:25

people are gatekeepers. And these

14:27

people are causing harm and basically trying to

14:30

salt the ground for actual Native people to

14:32

participate. So it's a

14:34

pretty similar idea there too. But Angel,

14:36

the difference with Jacqueline, I think, is

14:39

in her methodology. Well, yeah,

14:41

I mean, if you're going to publicly release

14:43

a list of names and then start investigating,

14:45

that's kind of ass backwards. Well, I mean,

14:47

well, as you heard, Jacqueline disputes that

14:49

the list was truly public. And

14:52

she disputes the idea that simply being on the

14:54

list hurt anyone. If anything, she says it

14:56

gives them a chance to prove who they are. But

14:59

in a minute, you're going to hear from someone who is

15:01

put on her list and who feels pretty

15:03

differently about the whole thing. Every

15:12

day is filled with opportunities to

15:14

express yourself. And with an everyday

15:16

piece from Blue Nile, you can do

15:18

it without saying a word. Blue Nile's

15:20

collection of diamond jewelry is the ultimate

15:23

statement with sparkle that elevates any outfit

15:25

or switch things up with a sapphire

15:27

piece sure to spark conversation. Either

15:30

way, their diamond guarantee ensures you get

15:32

the highest quality at the best price.

15:35

Express yourself with Blue Nile, the

15:37

original online jeweler at bluenile.com. That's

15:40

bluenile.com. My

15:47

name is Kiroz Old. I'm Pamanki. The

15:49

Pamanki Indian tribe is the only federally

15:51

recognized tribe in the state of Virginia.

15:53

I served on the board of

15:55

directors for Native American Lifelines of Baltimore

15:57

and Boston as a group of people.

16:00

have asked the president and I'm proud

16:02

of that service. Thank you. Hyruss

16:04

is active online. He's the founder

16:06

and moderator of Indian Country, which is

16:08

the biggest indigenous forum on Reddit. His

16:10

first encounter with Jacqueline Keeler happened online.

16:14

We disagreed with something on something

16:16

on Twitter. I think it's that petty. I

16:19

don't think Shaverford gave me for that. After

16:21

that, his name appeared on Jacqueline's list. So

16:24

I have to ask if he's on the list,

16:26

is he a pretendian? We

16:28

looked into his background and there's enough there

16:30

to show that he almost certainly is not

16:33

a pretendian. His mother and

16:35

grandmother had tribal membership. He himself

16:37

has chosen not to pursue a tribal ID, but

16:39

he is a claimed and very active member of

16:41

the Pamunkey community. He's not relying

16:43

on some distant ancestor or generalized descent.

16:46

I'm embraced as Pamunkey by other Pamunkey

16:48

people. Good enough for me. So

16:50

during the pandemic, when Kyruss was involved

16:52

in getting native people vaccinated, he learned

16:54

that his name was on Jacqueline's list. I

16:57

came to find that I, along

17:00

with about 200 other individuals

17:03

targeted, were part of

17:05

the alleged pretendians list in

17:08

the last days of January

17:11

2021. It was the one-year anniversary

17:14

of the loss of our child. And

17:16

it's an unsubstantiated

17:19

allegation. Kyruss says that even

17:21

though he was the individual named, his whole

17:23

family was implicated, and not just

17:25

the living. We're talking about our

17:28

dead, who's legitimacy is questioned, by

17:30

persons who have no relationship to him. And so

17:32

I saw one day she was making an attack

17:35

about my mother having

17:37

financed her home in

17:39

DC from fraudulent Pamunkey

17:41

claims, fundraising based

17:44

off of false claims. And I

17:46

pushed back on that publicly because my parents financed

17:48

that home through a mortgage funded

17:50

through their jobs. They were teachers

17:52

in DC public schools. I asked

17:54

Kyruss how Jacqueline Keeler's allegations impacted

17:56

him. I mean, it hasn't impacted

17:58

me negatively economically. because I didn't make money

18:01

off of indigene. It's not my bread and butter. I

18:03

don't do this stuff for a living.

18:05

But that's not to say he didn't suffer from it. After

18:08

the list went around, others took it upon

18:10

themselves to harass people who appeared on it.

18:13

I've unfortunately dealt with the criminal element who

18:15

she directed at my family. And

18:17

I had to tighten up security measures.

18:20

I had felt less safe.

18:22

And it's gotten somewhat better

18:25

insofar as I've gotten used to looking

18:27

over my shoulder in this capacity. I've

18:29

been less inclined, and I've

18:31

seen other people affected by this, being less

18:33

inclined to share of themselves in

18:35

other communities and other families because there are

18:38

sharks. There are monsters in

18:40

those digital waters. And she's certainly one of them.

18:42

As disturbing as all of us has been to

18:45

Kairos, he says that it's not really new. He

18:48

sees Jacqueline Keeler's list as a

18:50

new digital form of something that's

18:52

plague-native for generations. So

18:54

under the Racial Integrity Act of 1924,

18:57

the legislators in

18:59

Virginia who were among

19:01

the first families of Virginia, some of

19:03

whom have documented ancestry going back to

19:05

Pocahontas, wanted to carve

19:08

out an exception to this act

19:10

that defined in very

19:13

hard ways race in Virginia, setting

19:15

up a racial regime in which

19:17

you could be white

19:20

if you had distant

19:22

Indian ancestry. All

19:25

of the persons were considered

19:27

colored or black. And

19:30

then there was this tiny

19:32

Indian category that eugenics

19:34

did everything they could to persecute

19:37

and repress and

19:39

identify as suspect

19:41

and fraudulent so they could keep the

19:43

white race peers, so they could keep in their

19:46

language, they can keep these

19:48

Negroes from passing

19:51

into the white race by calling themselves

19:53

Indian on documents such as birth certificates.

19:56

It's worth noting here that Kairos is both

19:58

black and native. the

20:00

Jim Crow regime very much wanted to know

20:02

where people lived, where they worked, who they

20:05

were married to, who their friends were, where

20:07

they went to church. A total

20:09

invasion of the lives of these people and

20:11

the safety of these people. And you have

20:13

to remember that there were

20:15

felony penalties for violating the Racial Integrity

20:18

Act. People did, in

20:20

fact, find themselves imprisoned. So

20:22

it just strikes us as

20:25

being Jim Crow rebranded for the digital

20:27

age, because it's the same information, the

20:29

same persons used in the same way. Whether

20:31

you want to call it a use of slur

20:34

pretendian, or if you want

20:36

to use an older slur like mongrel,

20:38

which is what they would refer to us as. So

20:41

yeah, it's all had a bad

20:43

policy. And I'm used to people

20:45

demanding what my business is. Oh,

20:48

did you really earn the job that you have?

20:50

Or are you a diversity fire? Oh,

20:52

what are you doing here in this neighborhood? That's

20:54

how it hits me to say that my

20:56

parents didn't earn their home. We're used to

20:58

that. We're used to the idea that people like

21:00

us don't belong where we are. I

21:03

just find it has just a very rotten heart

21:05

of hate. She's a direct

21:07

successor to it in methodology and in rhetoric

21:10

and in targets, direct successor. So

21:12

I mean, Jacqueline said that she's just doing

21:14

investigative journalism. She

21:17

says that work should be looked at

21:19

as reporting on fraud. She

21:22

did say that she's just

21:24

doing investigative journalism. She also

21:26

said that she always tries to get the other

21:28

side of the story as any journalist would. Kyra

21:31

says that's not true. She never tried talking

21:33

with me at all. No outreach,

21:36

no interview. It's all been very dehumanizing because

21:38

it's like we're dealing with

21:40

some kind of wannabe anthropologist who

21:42

doesn't talk with their subjects, who

21:44

just writes about them and places

21:47

things in the most hostile, antagonistic,

21:50

derogatory light. We're not talking about professionals.

21:53

We're not talking about political journalists here.

21:55

We are talking about agitators and people

21:58

who are trying to get the right to work.

22:00

trying to prop themselves up using

22:02

clout and controversy and inference.

22:06

What is the term? Speculative journalism.

22:08

She's really stolen our

22:10

story and created something else. Paris

22:13

says that since the list, some natives

22:15

have gotten really paranoid. I've seen people

22:18

who on social media feel

22:20

compelled to dox themselves to present

22:22

their tribal ID and other personally

22:24

identifiable information that they need to keep

22:26

secure because they're afraid of being

22:28

called frauds. It's created an

22:31

environment of fear. Unfortunately, I'm part of

22:33

that environment of fear, an unwilling participant

22:35

in all this. I'm just curious

22:38

though, does Kiro see any kind of

22:40

value in the intent of this kind

22:42

of work? I mean, there's

22:44

widespread understanding that Pratindians are a

22:46

real problem. Yeah, he thinks

22:48

that tribal governments and only

22:50

tribal governments should be doing

22:52

these investigations and given

22:54

his experience, I don't really blame him. I

22:57

think people need to understand that it's not

22:59

normal for someone

23:01

to make a list of 200 enemies

23:04

digging down into where they live,

23:07

who their family is, digging up

23:09

their family trees, creating, fabricating new

23:11

family trees, pissing on those family

23:13

trees, degrading those ancestors

23:15

who can't speak for themselves. You

23:24

know, Kiroz was saying that the only people that

23:27

should be doing these sorts of investigations are tribal

23:29

governments. And I

23:32

was actually hired by my First

23:34

Nation to do one

23:36

of these sorts of investigations. And

23:38

so I appreciate what he's saying there. And

23:41

I think that applies when you have

23:44

an identifiable nation and

23:46

someone is claiming to be part

23:48

of that. When you've got

23:50

stories like Guillaume Karl, who

23:52

we did a while ago, or the Hells

23:54

Angels one a while ago, where they're making

23:56

up nations, I think there's a

23:59

place for... external actors to come in and

24:01

take a look at that. But I don't

24:03

think he's wrong. Yeah, I

24:05

have real bad issues with Jacqueline's

24:08

methodology. It seems like

24:10

she's kind of holding people hostage in

24:12

a court of public opinion that they

24:14

have absolutely no way

24:16

of refuting because a lie can be around

24:18

the world and back

24:20

again before the truth ever puts its shoes

24:22

on. And I think that if

24:25

she had done a few key things differently, I

24:28

could really support the work that she's

24:30

doing. But it is fucking crazy to

24:32

just make a list of

24:34

your 200 enemies and start blasting on

24:36

one social that's bullying. You're right, it

24:38

is bullying. There is a

24:40

problem in Indian country. We all

24:42

agree that there is a problem. She agrees,

24:45

we agree, we all agree that

24:47

there is an issue with these

24:49

pretendians taking opportunities, talking

24:51

over us. And it's

24:55

like an illness in our culture,

24:57

in our country. And you

25:00

can take a surgical approach and take it

25:02

out carefully, being as minimally

25:04

invasive as possible and making sure you don't

25:06

hurt anybody. Or you could

25:08

use a shotgun. And

25:11

some of the pellets will go past

25:13

and hit bystanders, but a couple

25:15

will actually hit the thing. And so, well, there we

25:17

go. Sloppy. For

25:19

all of the cases where you get it right, it

25:22

doesn't justify any of

25:24

the cases where you get it wrong. Absolutely

25:27

not. I hate to think about what

25:29

Kiroz and his mom and his grandmother

25:32

had to go and do in

25:34

their own community when these kind

25:36

of things started circulating. You know,

25:38

Kiroz isn't the only false positive that we talk

25:40

to. He's the only false positive that

25:43

would talk on tape because the others were afraid.

25:45

And they were afraid of the harassment that

25:47

they've gotten because of the list. And

25:50

it's quieted down for a little bit now. And

25:52

they were afraid that if they talked to us on tape,

25:55

that it would come back to them, that it would

25:57

restart everything all over again, and they would have to deal with

25:59

it. with people harassing

26:01

them online and possibly in

26:03

person. Hey Robert, I

26:05

got a question. So like, so

26:08

if we were to have like a

26:10

glaring mistake and someone pointed out holes

26:13

in our methodology, what would your first step

26:16

be? If we're like

26:18

a huge mistake, I would have to see

26:21

where my data was

26:24

bad. Okay, this

26:26

is the thing with Jacqueline Keeler. It's

26:29

hard to support her. She

26:31

makes it very hard. The

26:33

way she deals with people is

26:35

just not freaking cool.

26:38

It is just, it's not cool the way she deals

26:40

with people. It's not professional,

26:43

it's not humane.

26:46

When you put that aside, she

26:48

is doing a job that needs to be done.

26:51

And she is one of the

26:53

very, very few people who will do that job and

26:55

she has been right. And I

26:57

think that if she were

26:59

to change some of the ways

27:03

that she deals with things and with people,

27:06

that her contributions could be much

27:08

greater than they are now, much

27:10

greater than they have been so far. I'm

27:18

sorry. And

27:27

that's our show. Next

27:34

time on Pretendians, Angel zooms in on

27:36

Pretendians in Hollywood. Johnny Depp is

27:38

now a member of a Comanche family and

27:40

has an Indian name that suits him perfectly.

27:43

And Shaggy Pifter. Our

27:45

executive producer and editor is Jesse Brown. Additional

27:48

production from Caleb Thompson. Julie Shapiro

27:50

is our contributing editor. Canada

27:52

Land's editor in chief is Karen Pulezi. If

27:56

you like Pretendians and want to hear more of

27:58

it, it's really important to help us. the word out.

28:00

When you follow us, subscribe to us, rate

28:02

us, and review us on Spotify and

28:05

Apple podcasts, the sacred algorithm takes note

28:07

and spreads the word to others. Please

28:09

do it now. You can listen

28:11

ad-free and early on Amazon Music included with

28:13

Prime. Thanks for listening. I'm

28:21

guessing that most of the Canadians listening to this

28:23

right now already listen to Canada Land. The Americans

28:26

and not so sure. For over

28:28

10 years, Canada Land has been publishing weekly

28:30

episodes that look critically at the media, break

28:32

news stories, and bring listeners like you, perspectives

28:35

from across Canada that you won't find anywhere

28:37

else. Angel, since you

28:39

started working on the show, have you

28:41

been listening? Have you been catching up

28:43

on all things across the medicine line?

28:45

People are always telling me that you

28:47

Canadians are nice, polite, boring folks, but

28:49

I've been listening to some news

28:52

stories and holy cow, the

28:54

stereotypes are wrong. You guys

28:56

are wild. I've heard stories

28:58

about medical cover-ups, election

29:00

interference, right-wing trolls,

29:02

racism, messed up policing,

29:05

and something called a pokaroo. Anyway,

29:08

you guys are like the US but with less

29:10

guns and a younger, better-looking president or

29:12

leader, whatever you call him. I've

29:15

learned a lot. Yep, Canadians are just as

29:17

awful and outrageous and messed up as Americans

29:19

are. They just hide it better. I'm learning

29:21

that, Robert. You can listen to

29:23

and follow Canada Land anywhere you get your

29:25

podcasts. The

29:29

living room is where you make

29:31

life's most beautiful memories, but your sofa

29:33

shouldn't be the one remembering them. The

29:36

new life-resistant high-performance furniture collection from

29:38

Ashley is designed to withstand all the

29:40

spills, slip-ups, and muddy paws that come

29:42

with the best parts of life. Ashley

29:45

high-performance sofas and recliners are

29:48

soft, on-trend, and easy to

29:50

clean. Shop the high-performance furniture

29:52

in-store online at ashley.com. Ashley,

29:54

for the love of home.

30:00

of Freeze Your Bones, a

30:02

prospect. Searching for a legendary

30:04

cursed gold mine vanishes

30:06

without a trace. I'm Crewe

30:08

Williams, the host of Dead Man's

30:10

Curse. This season, we retrace the

30:12

steps of fortune seekers looking for

30:14

a mother lode worth billions who

30:16

never came back. So come

30:19

join our quest. Search for and follow

30:21

Dead Man's Curse Volcanic Gold on

30:23

Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, and

30:26

wherever you find your favorite podcasts.

30:30

Search for and follow Dead Man's Curse Volcanic Gold

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features